Another factor that contributed to the large loss of life
in both the Triangle and Kader fires was the lack of adequate
fire safety training, and the rigid security procedures
of both companies.
After the fire at the Kader facility, survivors reported
that fire drills and fire safety training were minimal,
although the security guards had apparently had some incipient
fire training. The Triangle Shirtwaist factory had no evacuation
plan, and fire drills were not implemented. Furthermore,
post-fire reports from Triangle survivors indicate that
they were routinely stopped as they left the building at
the end of the work day for security purposes. Various post-fire
accusations by Kader survivors also imply that security
arrangements slowed their exit, although these accusations
are still being investigated. In any case, the lack of a
well-understood evacuation plan seems to have been an important
factor in the high loss of life sustained in the Kader fire.
Chapter 31 of the Life Safety Code addresses fire drills
and evacuation training.
The absence of fixed automatic fire protection systems
also affected the outcome of both the Triangle and the Kader
fires. Neither facility was equipped with automatic sprinklers,
although the Kader buildings did have a fire alarm system.
According to the Life Safety Code, fire alarms should be
provided in buildings whose size, arrangement or occupancy
make it unlikely that the occupants themselves will notice
a fire immediately. Unfortunately, the alarms reportedly
never operated in Building One, which resulted in a significant
delay in evacuation. There were no fatalities in Buildings
Two and Three, where the fire alarm system functioned as
intended.
Fire alarm systems should be designed, installed and maintained
in accordance with documents like NFPA 72, the National
Fire Alarm Code (NFPA 72, 1993). Sprinkler systems should
be designed and installed in accordance with documents like
NFPA 13, Installation of Sprinkler Systems, and maintained
in accordance with NFPA 25, Inspection, Testing, and Maintenance
of Water-Based Fire Protection Systems (NFPA 13, 1994; NFPA
25, 1995).
The initial fuel packages in both the Triangle and Kader
fires were similar. The Triangle fire started in rag bins
and quickly spread to combustible clothing and garments
before involving wood furnishings, some of which were impregnated
with machine oil. The initial fuel package at the Kader
plant consisted of polyester and cotton fabrics, various
plastics, and other materials used to manufacture stuffed
toys, plastic dolls, and other related products. These are
materials that can typically be ignited easily, can contribute
to rapid fire growth and spread, and have a high heat release
rate.
Industry will probably always handle materials that have
challenging fire protection characteristics, but manufacturers
should recognize these characteristics and take the necessary
precautions to minimize associated hazards.
|