Among the fire protection principles on which the Kader
fire has focused attention are exit design, occupant fire
safety training, automatic detection and suppression systems,
fire separations and structural integrity. These lessons
are not new. They were first taught more than 80 years ago
at the Triangle Shirtwaist fire and again, more recently,
in a number of other fatal workplace fires, including those
at the chicken-processing plant in Hamlet, North Carolina,
USA, that killed 25 workers; at a doll factory in Kuiyong,
China, that killed 81 workers; and at the electrical power
plant in Newark, New Jersey, USA, that killed all 3 workers
in the plant (Grant and Klem 1994; Klem 1992; Klem and Grant
1993).
The fires in North Carolina and New Jersey, in particular,
demonstrate that the mere availability of state-of-the-art
codes and standards, such as NFPA's Life Safety Code, cannot
prevent tragic losses. These codes and standards must also
be adopted and rigorously enforced if they are to have any
effect.
National, state and local public authorities should examine
the way they enforce their building and fire codes to determine
whether new codes are needed or existing codes need to be
updated. This review should also determine whether a building
plan review and inspection process is in place to ensure
that the appropriate codes are followed. Finally, provisions
must be made for periodic follow-up inspections of existing
buildings to ensure that the highest levels of fire protection
are maintained throughout the life of the building.
Building owners and operators must also be aware that they
are responsible for ensuring that their employees' working
environment is safe. At the very least, the state-of-the-art
fire protection design reflected in fire codes and standards
must be in place to minimize the possibility of a catastrophic
fire.
Had the Kader buildings been equipped with sprinklers and
working fire alarms, the loss of life might not have been
so high. Had Building One's exits been better designed,
hundreds of people might not have been injured jumping from
the third and fourth floors. Had vertical and horizontal
separations been in place, the fire might not have spread
so quickly throughout the building. Had the buildings' structural
steel members been fireproofed, the buildings might not
have collapsed.
Philosopher George Santayana has written: “Those
who forget the past are condemned to repeat it.” The
Kader Fire of 1993 was unfortunately, in many ways, a repeat
of the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire of 1911. As we look to the
future, we need to recognize all that we need to do, as
a global society, to prevent history from repeating itself.
|